Amina asked 3 years ago
Question: Hi,
I hope this finds you well.
I’m marrying a Sunni guy who wants to do the marriage the Sunni way with a Sunni sheikh.
My family wants us to do it both the Sunni and Shia way.
So I would do one in the Sunni mosque with the sunni sheikh, and one with a Shia sheikh.
Is it permissible to do the marriage ceremony two different ways, resulting in two contracts?
mehdi answered 3 years ago
بِسْمِ ٱللَّٰهِ ٱلرَّحْمَٰنِ ٱلرَّحِيمِ
As Salaamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh,
We hope this answer reaches you in good health and Islamic spirit.
Kindly, accept our apologies for any delayed response, due to heavy load of questions.
Based on your specific question and information provided.
Since the Islamic Law is for all time and condition(s). Review and understand all laws and Exceptions applicable to your particular situation in the Section on Marriage see link below.
The Exception of the “Marriage Contract” between Shia and Sunni is Mubah ( Optional / at your discretion ), given that one does Not fear for their (Aqeeda) beliefs. (*)
Having understood the above conditions.
According to Islamic Law, Two contracts are allowed as long as there is no change in the terms and conditions of both contracts.
( Allah(awj) Knows best).
I hope this answers your question. If you have further questions kindly contact us at (718) 297-6520 Ext 113 Monday to Saturday between 11:AM – 3:00 PM.
mehdi answered 1 year ago
The Islamic Scholars have divided the Islamic teachings in three parts.
1) Fundamental of Faith (Belief / Aqidah)
2) Islamic Ethics / Morals,
3) Islamic Law/ Fiqh / Jurisprudence.
The “institution of Marriage” is covered by all three.
The “Marriage Contract” is cover by Islamic Jurisprudence.
From the Islamic Jurisprudence perspective.
مسألة 215: يجوز زواج المؤمن من المخالفة غير الناصبية، كما يجوز زواج المؤمنة من المخالف غير الناصبي، على كراهة، نعم إذا خيف عليه أو عليها الضلال حرم.
منهاج الصالحين – السيد السيستاني – ج ٣ – الصفحة ٧٠
Minhaj al-Salihin – Sayyid al-Sistani – Part 3 – Page 70 : Edition 7: Year 1998.
Rough English Translation(you should consult an Arabic speaking person or take it to your local Mosque to the scholar to explain the proper Arabic words/terminology/essence). :
“It is allowed for the believer to marry a woman from the other sect, (on the condition that she is ) not a Nasabi (Nawasib) and it is allowed for the believing woman to marry a person from the other sect (on the condition) he is not a Nasabi (Nawasib) , and it is ( كراهة ) (Makrooh / Not recommended). If there is fear on him or her that they will be misguided ( go astray/ loose Imami Shia Faith/ Aqidah / Fiqh ) than it is ( حرم) ( Haram / Forbidden ).
Updated explanation of the last sentence above (1) ( نعم إذا خيف عليه أو عليها الضلال حرم)
مسألة 215: يجوز زواج المؤمن من المخالفة غير الناصبيّة، كما يجوز زواج المؤمنة من المخالف غير الناصبيّ على كراهة، نعم يحرم إذا خيف عليه أو عليها من أن يؤدّي إلى الانحراف في العقيدة أو المنع من أداء الوظائف الشرعيّة وفق مذهب الإماميّة.
Rough translation of the highlighted text :
Yes, it is (Haram) forbidden if it is feared that he or she will lead to a deviation in the ( العقيدة ) Creed / Aqidah or prevent him/her from performing the Islamic Shari’ a duties according to the ( مذهب الإماميّة ) Imami school of thought ( Fiqh / Jurisprudence).
********************
Note: Nawasib (i.e. those who are enemies of (the Holy Imams (عليه السلام) and Sayyida Fatima al-Zahra (sa) ), are impure.
(*) Related.
https://www.al-khoei.org/Questions/sunni-and-shia-marriage-2/
https://www.al-khoei.org/Questions/marriage-between-two-muslims-of-different-sects-aqeeda/
https://www.al-khoei.org/Questions/can-a-syeda-girl-marry-a-sunni-guy/
Please login or Register to submit your answer